Why We Believe Longer Cruises Are Better (And Which Cruise Line Fits You Best)

For us, cruising has become one of our favorite ways to travel—not because it’s flashy or trendy, but because when it’s done right, cruising offers something increasingly rare: real rest paired with real value. And here’s our hot take (earned the hard way):

7-night or longer cruises are where cruising truly shines.

Short cruises can be fun. Longer cruises can be transformational. Let’s break down why—and then compare five major cruise lines so you can decide which one fits your travel style best.

Why 7+ Night Cruises Are the Sweet Spot

Short cruises (3–4 nights) tend to feel rushed. They’re often party-heavy, port-light, and packed with people trying to squeeze everything into a few days. There’s nothing wrong with that—but it’s not why we cruise.

Here’s what changes once you hit 7 nights or more:

• You actually relax. It takes a few days to unplug. Longer cruises give you time to settle into the rhythm of sea days, slow mornings, and intentional rest.
• Better itineraries. Longer cruises usually include better ports, fewer “tourist trap” stops, and more time ashore.
• Stronger value. When you average out the cost per night—food, lodging, entertainment, transportation—longer cruises almost always win.
• A different crowd. You’ll generally find fewer party cruisers and more couples, families, and seasoned travelers who value the journey, not just the destination.

Comparing the Major Cruise Lines

Not all cruise lines are created equal—and that’s a good thing. Each one serves a different kind of traveler.

MSC Cruises – European Flair, Excellent Value

MSC Cruises is often overlooked by U.S.-based travelers, but it shouldn’t be—especially for longer sailings. MSC brings a distinctly European vibe, modern ships, and some of the best pricing in cruising.

Best for:

• Value-focused travelers
• Mediterranean itineraries
• Modern ships & quieter onboard atmosphere

B2G Take:
MSC really shines on 7–10 night cruises, where you have time to appreciate the ship, the international feel, and the pacing. It’s not a party cruise—and that’s a feature, not a bug.

Carnival – Fun, Social, and Short-Cruise Heavy

Carnival Cruise Line is often people’s first cruise—and for good reason. It’s fun, affordable, and accessible. But Carnival truly excels on shorter sailings.

Best for:

• First-time cruisers
• Groups and social travelers
• Budget-conscious short trips

B2G Take:
Carnival can work for longer cruises, but it’s not where it shines. If you’re looking for deep relaxation and slower pacing, there are better fits—especially for 7+ nights.

Royal Caribbean – Big Ships, Big Experiences

Royal Caribbean is the cruise line for travelers who want everything. Rock climbing, Broadway-style shows, massive ships, and itineraries all over the world.

Best for:

• Families
• Active travelers
• Travelers who want nonstop options

B2G Take:
Royal Caribbean does long cruises well, especially when paired with sea days. Just know that “relaxation” here often means choosing to step away from the action.

Holland America – Slow Travel at Sea

Holland America Line is where cruising slows down—in the best possible way. Longer itineraries, enrichment programs, and a refined onboard experience define this line.

Best for:

• Couples
• Older travelers
• Destination-focused itineraries

B2G Take:
If your idea of a perfect cruise includes quiet mornings, thoughtful dining, and meaningful ports, Holland America is built for 7–14 night sailings.

Margaritaville at Sea – Niche and Novelty

Margaritaville at Sea is exactly what it sounds like: casual, themed, and unapologetically short-cruise focused.

Best for:

• Quick getaways
• Fans of the brand
• No-frills fun

B2G Take:
This is not a long-cruise option—and it’s not trying to be. Fun for a few nights, but not built for depth, exploration, or extended relaxation.

Our Bottom Line

Cruising isn’t just about getting on a ship—it’s about giving yourself permission to slow down.. For us, that happens at 7 nights or longer, where:

• The ship becomes familiar
• The stress melts away
• The journey matters as much as the ports

If you’re choosing a cruise line:

• Want value and modern ships → MSC
• Want nonstop fun → Royal Caribbean
• Want refined, intentional travel → Holland America
• Want short, social trips → Carnival or Margaritaville

Cruising done right isn’t about cramming everything in. It’s about creating space—for rest, connection, and being better together along the way.